English
NASA Faces Criticism Over All-Male Artemis III Crew Selection
NASA is facing intense backlash after announcing an all-male crew for the Artemis III mission, a critical test flight scheduled for 2027 that will prepare for the first crewed lunar landing in over 50 years. The decision has drawn sharp criticism from astronauts, scientists, and the public, who note that women make up 40% of NASA's active astronaut corps.
The crew announced on June 9, 2026, includes Commander Randy Bresnik (NASA), Pilot Luca Parmitano (ESA), and Mission Specialists Frank Rubio and Andre Douglas (both NASA). NASA astronaut Bob Hines serves as backup. All four prime crew members are men, marking the first all-male NASA crew for a major mission since 2021.
Why the Artemis III Crew Selection Matters
The Artemis program is named after the Greek goddess Artemis, the twin sister of Apollo — a symbolic choice intended to signal a new era of inclusion in space exploration. NASA had previously committed to landing the first woman and the first person of color on the Moon through the Artemis program. Critics argue that the all-male Artemis III crew contradicts that vision.
Emily Calandrelli, a science communicator who flew on Blue Origin's New Shepard, called the decision "teleurstellend" (disappointing) on Instagram: "Artemis is de tweelingzus van Apollo. Laten we deze fout niet meer maken." Science communicator Camille Bergin ("The Space Gal") said the selection "voelt alsof we een stap terug maken."
The Artemis program goals have always emphasized diversity, making this crew choice particularly jarring for many observers.
NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman Defends the Decision
NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman, himself a commercial astronaut who flew on Inspiration4 and Polaris Dawn, responded to the criticism on X (formerly Twitter). He stated that crew selection is based purely on expertise, mission requirements, and availability — not gender or politics.
"Niemand moet hier iets achter zoeken," Isaacman wrote. "Onze laatste astronautenklas bestond voor meer dan de helft uit vrouwen. We selecteren de beste astronauten om onze doelen te bereiken."
Isaacman emphasized that several female astronauts were not assigned to Artemis III because they were already training for International Space Station expeditions or were considered better suited for later Artemis missions, including the actual lunar landing on Artemis IV. He noted that NASA's Astronaut Office — which includes no political appointees — makes crew assignments based on factors like test pilot experience, program development involvement, and specialized training.
Who Are the Artemis III Astronauts?
- Randy Bresnik (Commander): NASA astronaut, retired US Marine Corps colonel, former ISS commander with over 149 days in space.
- Luca Parmitano (Pilot): ESA astronaut, Italian Air Force test pilot, former ISS commander — the first European assigned to an Artemis mission.
- Frank Rubio (Mission Specialist): US Army helicopter pilot, flight surgeon, holds the record for the longest single spaceflight by a US astronaut (371 days).
- Andre Douglas (Mission Specialist): NASA's newest astronaut, former Coast Guard commander, engineer and robotics specialist making his first spaceflight.
What Artemis III Will Actually Do
Despite its name, Artemis III will not land on the Moon. Instead, it is a complex test flight in low Earth orbit designed to evaluate rendezvous and docking operations between Orion and commercial lunar landers being developed by SpaceX (Starship) and Blue Origin (Blue Moon). The mission involves three separate rocket launches — the most complex human spaceflight test since Apollo.
The crew will spend approximately two weeks in orbit, testing spacecraft systems, radiation protection, and crew operations. A successful mission would pave the way for Artemis IV in 2028, which aims to land astronauts on the lunar South Pole for the first time in 54 years.
The Artemis IV lunar landing mission is expected to include a more diverse crew, potentially including the first woman on the Moon.
Reactions from the Space Community
Sian Proctor, who flew with Isaacman on Inspiration4 in 2021 as the first African American woman to pilot a spacecraft, struck a hopeful tone. "Felicitaties aan de crew van Artemis III. Jullie succes zal de weg bereiden voor de volledig vrouwelijke crew van Artemis IV!" she posted on social media.
Other critics were less diplomatic. Alexandra Doten, a space communicator, called the all-male crew "insane" given NASA's diverse astronaut pool. Out of 37 active NASA astronauts, 15 are women — roughly 40%. Since SpaceX began ferrying astronauts to the ISS in 2021, all-male crews have become rare, occurring only twice, including once for an emergency medical evacuation.
The diversity in NASA's astronaut corps is a point of pride for the agency, making this selection a notable departure from recent trends.
FAQ: Artemis III Crew Controversy
Why is the Artemis III crew all male?
NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman stated the crew was selected based on expertise, mission needs, and availability. Several qualified female astronauts were already assigned to ISS missions or are being prepared for later Artemis flights, including the lunar landing.
How many women are in NASA's astronaut corps?
As of 2026, 15 of NASA's 37 active astronauts are women — approximately 40%. The agency's most recent astronaut candidate class (2021) was over 50% female.
Will women be on future Artemis missions?
Yes. NASA has stated that women will be assigned to Artemis IV and subsequent missions, including the first crewed lunar landing. The agency remains committed to landing the first woman on the Moon.
When will Artemis III launch?
Artemis III is currently targeted for 2027, pending readiness of the SLS rocket, Orion spacecraft, and commercial lunar landers from SpaceX and Blue Origin.
What is the difference between Artemis III and Artemis IV?
Artemis III is a test flight in low Earth orbit to verify docking and systems interoperability. Artemis IV, planned for 2028, will be the first crewed mission to land on the lunar surface since Apollo 17 in 1972.
Follow Discussion