‘Shocking Amateurism’ in US-Russia Negotiations

Tensions between the US and Russia have escalated, with both sides exchanging insults and no ceasefire in sight. Experts criticize the negotiations as amateurish, citing poorly conceived proposals and a lack of strategic foresight.

‘Shocking Amateurism’ in US-Russia Negotiations
Share
Edition: EN

The atmosphere between Washington and Moscow has deteriorated in recent weeks. The two superpowers are exchanging harsh words, and a ceasefire deal in Ukraine seems far from reach. ‘This makes no sense; it’s pure amateurism,’ says Rob de Wijk from The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies (HCSS) in News Clearly’s Boekestijn en De Wijk.

The tone in communication between spokespersons and on social media has hardened since US President Trump suggested that his Russian counterpart Putin is unwilling to accelerate the peace process. Trump called Putin ‘completely deranged’ on his platform Truth Social after Russia launched another large-scale air attack on Ukraine. Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov dismissed Trump’s reaction as ‘a bit emotional,’ while Trump countered that Putin is ‘playing with fire’ and that ‘very bad things’ would have happened to Russia without him—prompting sharp responses from the Russians.

‘It’s total madness,’ says De Wijk. ‘These are supposed to be leaders of superpowers trying to negotiate a ceasefire, and they’re just insulting each other. This is pure amateurism.’

The amateurism doesn’t stop there. According to De Wijk, some of the US proposals for a ceasefire in Ukraine are poorly thought out—for example, recognizing Crimea as Russian territory. ‘No one considered the consequences for territorial waters and economic zones in the Black Sea,’ he says. ‘A ceasefire with Trump’s concessions could lead to a confrontation between NATO member Romania and Russia in the Black Sea. It’s shocking amateurism, and I’ve never seen anything like it in my life.’

Closely related

US Envoy Lands in Moscow for Ukraine Peace Talks
Geopolitics
Geopolitics
Closely related

US Envoy Lands in Moscow for Ukraine Peace Talks

US diplomat Steve Witkoff arrived in Moscow for Ukraine peace talks amid Trump's sanctions threat if Russia doesn't...

Russia Demands International Recognition of Occupied Regions as Russian Territory
Geopolitics
Geopolitics
Closely related

Russia Demands International Recognition of Occupied Regions as Russian Territory

Russia demands Ukraine cede occupied territories and seeks international recognition of these regions as Russian,...

Trump-Brokered Ceasefire: 3-Day Truce Between Ukraine and Russia
War
War
Closely related

Trump-Brokered Ceasefire: 3-Day Truce Between Ukraine and Russia

Trump announces a three-day ceasefire between Ukraine and Russia, including a 1,000-prisoner exchange. Both sides...

Ukraine and Russia Prepare for Largest Prisoner Swap Since War Began
War
War
Closely related

Ukraine and Russia Prepare for Largest Prisoner Swap Since War Began

Ukraine and Russia are preparing for their largest prisoner swap since the war began, with 1,000 prisoners to be...

Trump Sets 10-12 Day Deadline for Ukraine Peace Deal with Russia
Geopolitics
Geopolitics
Closely related

Trump Sets 10-12 Day Deadline for Ukraine Peace Deal with Russia

President Trump has shortened the deadline for a Russia-Ukraine ceasefire agreement to 10-12 days, threatening 100%...

Ukraine Proposes Direct Peace Talks with Russia Next Week
Geopolitics
Geopolitics
Closely related

Ukraine Proposes Direct Peace Talks with Russia Next Week

Ukraine proposes direct leader-level peace talks with Russia next week. Zelensky seeks ceasefire, prisoner...